The Screwball Times Expert. Juvenile. Baseball Insights.

Analysis: Never Make the First Out at Any Base

by Fred Hofstetter on September 3, 2017

Making the first out puts baseball teams at a serious disadvantage. Players who do not make the first out are more valuable.

Rickey Henderson was a tremendous baseball player – but notorious for making the first out. Photo Credit: Gary Stevens

New analysis reveals a troubling trend around Major League Baseball – general managers are repeatedly and knowingly acquiring players with extensive track records of making the first out – at any base.

Making the first out in baseball at any base puts offenses 33% closer to making three outs. Three outs ends the inning and hands the bats over to the other team – making the OTHER team 100% more likely to score runs. Players who make the first out at any base are the catalyst for every inning’s inevitable doom.


Making First Outs at Any Base is Particularly Bad, Mathematically.

Major League baseball teams in 2017 must understand the importance of avoiding first outs at all costs. Average run expectancy on a per-inning basis plummets after the first out:

Run Expectancy
Average # of runs scored Chance run will score in inning
0 out, no one on 0.481 0.268
1 out, no one on 0.254 0.155
% decrease 47% 42%

Making the first out at third base is cataclysmic. I crunched the numbers:

Run Expectancy – When First Out Made at Third Base
Average # of runs scored Chance run will score in inning
0 out, no one on 0.481 0.268
After out made at 3rd or any base 0.254 0.155
% decrease 47% 42%

Getting Out is Just a Plain Bad Idea

It’s hard to believe for so long baseball has suffered from a complete lack of critical thinking and succumbed to brainless tradition. Why would you make an out at any base? The alternative is clearly superior – reaching base and NOT making an out. Without making an out, you put the other team in a very difficult position.

For too long we’ve idolized baseball “legends” who have glorified the out. Here’s a list of charlatans who’ve done the game a great disservice:

Overrated Player Outs Made
Pete Rose 10328
Hank Aaron 9136
Carl Yastrzemski 9126
Cal Ripken 8893
Eddie Murray 8569
Rickey Henderson 8510
Omar Vizquel 8433
Dave Winfield 8422
Robin Yount 8415
Brooks Robinson 8340
Craig Biggio 8272
Derek Jeter 8269
Luis Aparicio 8110
Willie Mays 8056
Paul Molitor 8040

Nobody's chimed in. Be the first.

Leave a Reply

The Latest Articles

MLB Collusion Almost Certainly the Work of International Supervillain

by Fred Hofstetter on January 17, 2018

MLB owners and front office executives cannot be fully credited with the circumvention of crippling free agent contracts and costly draft pick compensation. Behind the curtain assuredly lies a superior foe worthy of our awe and mortal fear.

In Defense of Baseball's Pythagorean Theorem

by Fred Hofstetter on November 8, 2017

Don La Greca undressed Pythagorean Theorem supporters in a florid rant on ESPN radio - a theorem with modest potential for widespread application.

Proposing New Designated Player Roles - Excellent Ideas for MLB

by Fred Hofstetter on September 13, 2017

Pitchers can't run the bases. Fielders can't hit. Let's explore specializing every corner of Major League Baseball - from the shortstop to the bat boy.

Baseball Fans Everywhere Furious to Know Players are Cheating

by Fred Hofstetter on September 6, 2017

The Boston Red Sox were caught cheating. They've been using Apple watches to steal signs. MLB fans around the league are furious to know about it.

Back to the blog All articles